Alice Mary Smith was the first British woman to have composed a symphony and have it performed. And what a fine work the C minor Symphony is, attractively tuneful throughout and with a fine grasp of orchestration and form Howard Shelley and the London Mozart Players are admirable advocates throughtout, and this CD is most enjoyable.
The Penguin Guide - 1000 Greatest Classical Recordings 2011-12
It would be hard to find more persuasive advocates than Howard Shelley and the brilliant Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra.
The Guardian on CHAN 9893 (Reinecke)
The models for her symphonies are fairly obviously Mendelssohn and Beethoven (the C minor, the earlier of the two here is actually more arresting) – but there is a shapeliness to her melodies which is highly attractive, and some striking ideas such as the lively trio in the A minor and the ‘amorevole’ slow movement in the C minor, which begins just like a Victorian ballad.
Manchester Evening News
We are in Chandos’ debt for restoring Smith to the company of her peers and allowing such spirited and enjoyable music to be heard again. Howard Shelley, whose services to the revival of Moscheles I have drawn attention to, directs very lively and nicely balanced performances from the London Mozart Players, who sound as if they were proud to be involved in this act of restitution. I would encourage anyone to buy this warmly revelatory disc.
International Record Review
Stylish, characterful performances from soloists and orchestra alike…
***** performance
***** sound
BBC Music Magazine on CHAN 9925 (Hummel)
Howard Shelley and the London Mozart Players own this repertoire are not likely to face any competition in the foreseeable future, if ever. The orchestra – one of the English capital’s finest by the way – offers this unusual fare in confident interpretations that grasps and tug at the curiosity of the listener. They also sustain the music’s initial appeal via an exceptional and sensitive balance of the printed page and consummate musicianship.
Fanfare
Howard Shelley as conductor proves the most compelling advocate, drawing warm, committed performances from his players.
Gramophone on CHAN 9893 (Reinecke)